Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to search

Who's Harmed?

VICTIM 1: Political Activists & Dissidents (Most Vulnerable)

The Retroactive Surveillance Threat:

How It Works:

Today (2024):

  • Activist: Uses Signal and ProtonMail (encrypted)
  • Sends: Messages organizing protests and sharing documents
  • Believes: Safe (end-to-end encrypted)
  • NSA/FBI: Collects encrypted messages (can't read now)

2035 (Hypothetical):

  • Quantum Computer: Breaks encryption (retroactively)
  • Government: Decrypts 10 years of messages
  • Activist: Now targeted (based on past communications)
  • Charges: Conspiracy, sedition, and terrorism (based on decrypted messages)
Real-World Scenarios:

Climate Activists:

  • 2024: Organize civil disobedience (pipeline blockades, etc.)
  • Communications: Encrypted (Signal groups, encrypted email)
  • 2035: Oil industry lobbies for crackdown (after major protest)
  • FBI: Uses decrypted messages (from 2024) to prosecute (10+ years later)
  • Charges: Domestic terrorism (based on planning messages)

Labor Organizers:

  • 2024: Secretly organizing union (Amazon warehouse, etc.)
  • Encrypted Chats: Discussing strategy and membership
  • 2030: Quantum breaks encryption
  • Company: Somehow accesses decrypted messages (government shares, or buys quantum access)
  • Fires: All organizers (retroactively identified)

Abortion Rights Activists (Post-Dobbs):

  • 2024: Helping people access abortion (travel funds, pills, and information)
  • Encrypted: To avoid prosecution in red states
  • 2035: Federal abortion ban passes (hypothetical)
  • DOJ: Decrypts messages and prosecutes helpers (10 years retroactively)
International Dissidents:

Uyghur Activists (China):

  • Currently: China surveils Uyghurs (facial recognition, phone monitoring, and DNA collection)
  • Quantum: Would allow China to decrypt Signal/WhatsApp messages (used by diaspora)
  • Result: Identify activists abroad and target families in Xinjiang

Russian Dissidents:

  • Encrypted Communications: With journalists and other activists
  • Russian Quantum: (if developed) decrypts retroactively
  • Targeted: For arrest, poisoning, and assassination

Saudi Dissidents:

  • Jamal Khashoggi: Murdered (2018) for journalism
  • Others: Use encryption (WhatsApp, Signal)
  • If Saudi Arabia: Accesses quantum (buys from U.S./China?)
  • Decrypts: Identifies dissidents and targets for killing

Scale:

  • Millions: Of activists globally rely on encryption
  • Quantum: Would expose all of them (retroactively)

VICTIM 2: Journalists & Sources

Source Protection:

How Journalism Works:

  • Whistleblower: Leaks documents to journalist (encrypted channels)
  • Journalist: Protects source identity (ethical obligation)
  • Encryption: Prevents government from identifying source

Examples:

  • Edward Snowden → Glenn Greenwald (2013): Used Tor, PGP encryption
  • Pentagon Papers (1971): Daniel Ellsberg → New York Times (pre-digital)
  • Panama Papers (2016): Anonymous → ICIJ (encrypted)
Quantum Breaks This:

Scenario:

2024:

  • Government Employee: Leaks documents (corruption, war crimes, etc.)
  • Sends: Via encrypted email (ProtonMail and Signal)
  • Journalist: Receives and publishes (source remains anonymous)

2035:

  • Government: Decrypts messages (retroactively, via quantum)
  • Identifies: Source (email metadata + content)
  • Prosecutes: Under Espionage Act (10+ years prison)
  • Chilling Effect: Future sources don't come forward
Real Cases (Would Be Worse With Quantum):

Reality Winner (2017):

  • NSA Contractor: Leaked document on Russian election interference
  • Caught: Via printer tracking dots (not encryption failure)
  • Sentenced: 5 years (longest sentence for leak to media at the time)

If Quantum Existed:

  • All Her Encrypted Communications: Decrypted
  • Government: Could identify other sources and conspirators
  • Harsher Sentence: Possible (more evidence)

Julian Assange (WikiLeaks):

  • Published: Classified documents (Iraq War Logs and Diplomatic Cables)
  • Sources: Used encryption (Chelsea Manning)
  • If Quantum: Could decrypt all WikiLeaks submissions (identify sources globally)

VICTIM 3: LGBTQ+ People & Marginalized Groups

Medical Privacy:

HIV Status:

  • Many people: Discuss HIV status via encrypted messaging
  • Medical Records: Also encrypted (HIPAA requires)
  • Quantum: Could decrypt (expose HIV status retroactively)

Scenario:

  • Person: Diagnosed HIV+ (2024), discusses with partner via Signal
  • 2035: Insurance companies access quantum-decrypted records (if regulations fail)
  • Denied: Coverage (pre-existing condition, if ACA repealed)
Gender-Affirming Care:

Trans Youth & Families:

  • Currently: Republican states ban gender-affirming care
  • Families: Use encrypted messaging (discuss care and travel to blue states)
  • If quantum: Retroactively decrypt messages
  • Prosecute: Parents (for "child abuse," as some states classify trans care)

Example:

  • Texas family (2024): Takes child to Colorado for puberty blockers
  • Discusses: Via Signal (believes messages are encrypted)
  • 2030: Texas gets access to decrypted messages (via federal cooperation?)
  • Charges: Child endangerment (removes child and prosecutes parents)
Sexual Orientation:

Closeted Individuals:

  • Many: Not publicly out (live in conservative areas, have homophobic families/employers)
  • Discuss: Sexual orientation via encrypted apps (dating apps, messaging)
  • Quantum: Could out them retroactively

Scenario:

  • Teacher in red state: Gay and uses Grindr (encrypted)
  • 2035: School district accesses decrypted data (via private quantum service?)
  • Fired: For "grooming" (as DeSantis-style laws claim)

VICTIM 4: Medical Patients (ALL OF US)

Health Records:

What's At Risk:

  • Mental health: Therapy notes and psychiatric diagnoses
  • Genetic Data: 23andMe and Ancestry.com (if hacked, or subpoenaed)
  • Reproductive health: Abortion records (post-Dobbs), contraception
  • Chronic Conditions: HIV, diabetes, and cancer (insurance discrimination)

How It's Currently Protected:

  • HIPAA: Requires encryption (for digital health records)
  • Encryption: AES-256 (quantum-vulnerable for older algorithms), RSA for key exchange (very vulnerable)
  • Quantum: Breaks RSA and could break older AES if keys are stored
Retroactive Exposure:

Scenario:

  • 2024: You discuss mental health (depression or suicidal ideation) with therapist via telehealth
  • Encrypted: Video call (TLS/SSL, uses RSA)
  • Stored: By telehealth company (encrypted backups)
  • 2035: Quantum breaks encryption
  • Insurance Company: Accesses decrypted records (via hack, purchase, or government sharing)
  • Denies: Coverage (pre-existing mental health condition)
Genetic Discrimination:

23andMe, Ancestry.com:

  • Users: Upload DNA (learn ancestry and health risks)
  • Data: Encrypted at rest (but company has decryption keys)
  • Quantum: Government or hackers could decrypt

Scenario:

  • Your DNA: Shows high risk for Alzheimer's, Huntington's
  • 2035: Employer or insurer accesses decrypted data
  • Denied: Job, insurance (genetic discrimination)
  • Even Though: GINA (Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act) prohibits this
    • Enforcement: Weak and hard to prove

VICTIM 5: Corporate Trade Secrets

Economic Espionage:

What's At Risk:

  • M&A plans: Company planning acquisition (encrypted emails)
  • Drug Formulas: Pharmaceutical R&D (encrypted databases)
  • Source code: Proprietary software (encrypted repos)
  • Financial Strategies: Hedge fund trades (encrypted communications)
How Espionage Works:

Chinese Espionage (Current):

  • China: Hacks U.S. companies (APT groups, state-sponsored)
  • Steals: Encrypted data (can't decrypt now)
  • Stores: Waiting for quantum

Quantum Future:

  • 2035: China has quantum computer
  • Decrypts: 10+ years of stolen corporate data
  • Uses: To boost Chinese companies (unfair advantage)
Examples:

Pfizer (Hypothetical):

  • Developed: COVID vaccine (encrypted R&D communications, 2020)
  • China: Hacked and stole encrypted data (couldn't decrypt)
  • 2035: Decrypts via quantum
  • Chinese Pharma: Copies vaccine (years of R&D stolen)

Boeing:

  • Military aircraft designs: Encrypted
  • China: Already steals (APT groups)
  • Quantum: Would allow access to all past designs (retroactively)

Who Loses:

  • U.S. companies: Lose competitive advantage
  • U.S. workers: Jobs lost (to Chinese competition)
  • Economy: Trillions in lost IP

VICTIM 6: Government Classified Information

National Security Secrets:

What's Classified:

  • Military plans: War strategies and troop movements
  • Intelligence: Spy identities and methods
  • Nuclear: Weapons designs and launch codes
  • Diplomatic: Negotiation positions and cables

How It's Protected:

  • Classified networks: Air-gapped (not connected to the internet)
  • Encryption: For transmission (when must send over wires)
  • Quantum: Would break encryption (if data is intercepted)
The Threat:

China/Russia Collection:

  • Already: Intercept U.S. government communications (satellite and cables)
  • Can't Decrypt: Now (strong encryption)
  • Store: Everything (waiting for quantum)

When Quantum Arrives:

  • 2035: China/Russia decrypt 10+ years of U.S. classified communications
  • Learn: Military strategies, intelligence methods, and diplomatic positions
  • Counterintelligence: Identify U.S. spies (executed)
Real Precedents:

OPM Hack (2015):

  • China: Hacked Office of Personnel Management
  • Stole: 22 million background check files (government employees and contractors)
  • Included: SF-86 forms (detailed personal info and security clearance applications)
  • Data: Encrypted (but encryption was weak or possibly broken)

If Quantum:

  • China: Could decrypt all OPM data (if still encrypted)
  • Identify: Every U.S. intelligence officer (from SF-86s)
  • Target: For recruitment, blackmail, or elimination

VICTIM 7: Ordinary Citizen (Everyone)

"I Have Nothing To Hide":

Why This Is Wrong:

You Don't Know What's Illegal in 10 Years:

  • 2024: Abortion is legal in many states
  • 2035: Federal ban (hypothetical)
  • Your 2024 Communications: About helping friend get abortion (now illegal retroactively)

You Don't Know Who's In Power:

  • 2024: Normal political climate (maybe)
  • 2035: Authoritarian government (hypothetical)
  • Your 2024 Criticisms: Of leaders (now prosecutable under sedition laws)

You Don't Know What's Considered Suspicious:

  • 2024: You research political topics (Islam, anarchism, encryption, etc.)
  • 2035: Surveillance AI flags you (based on decrypted browsing history)
  • Placed: On no-fly list, denied jobs, and harassed
Examples:

Political Speech:

  • 2024: You tweet "Eat the rich," "Guillotines for billionaires" (hyperbole, protected speech)
  • 2035: Authoritarian government decrypts DMs (you discussed revolution with friends)
  • Prosecuted: Incitement and terrorism (context is removed and jokes are taken seriously)

Religious/Ethnic Targeting:

  • 2024: Muslim American (encrypted WhatsApp with family abroad)
  • 2035: Government decrypts (sees discussions of politics and religion)
  • Flagged: As "extremist" (based on keywords and AI misinterpretation)
  • Raided: Home, arrested, and placed on a watchlist

Scale:

  • Every Person: Has communications they wouldn't want public
  • Quantum: Exposes everyone (selective enforcement targets dissidents)